Blog categories

HOME BIRTH RESOURCES
Need to Know

BACK
Jun 18, 2005 |
Need to Know,  |
Kellie Moeller, CNM

Home Birth is it Safe?

Author: Kenneth C Johnson and Betty-Anne Daviss
Publisher: British Medical Journal
Date Published: June 18, 2005

Safe & Healthy Outcomes

  • Results are consistent with most studies of planned home births and low risk hospital births
  • Zero maternal deaths
  • Intrapartum and neonatal mortality: 2.0 per 1000 intended home births (only 1.7 per 1000 intended
    home births when planned breech and twin births are excluded)
  • Immediate neonatal concerns resulted in just 2.4% of newborns being placed in neonatal intensive
    care
  • At six weeks well over 90% of mothers were still breastfeeding their babies

Low Rates of Medical Intervention

  • Much lower rates of interventions for intended home births compared to low risk hospital births:
     
    Planned home birth
    Hospital birth
    Induction of labor (only with oxytocin or prostaglandins)
    2.1% *
    21.0%
    Stimulation of labor (only with oxytocin)
    2.7% *
    18.9%
    Electronic fetal monitoring
    9.6%
    84.3%
    Episiotomy
    2.1%
    33.0%
    Vacuum Extraction
    0.6%
    5.5%
    Cesarean Section
    3.7%
    19.0%
    * These numbers differ from the BMJ article where data for CPMs included forms of induction and stimulation only used by midwives and not comparable to hospital births.

Satisfied Mothers

  • Only 1.7% of the mothers said they would choose a different type of caregiver for a future pregnancy

Few Transfers to Hospital Care

  • Only 12.1% transferred to hospital intrapartum or postpartum
  • Five out of six transfers were before delivery, most for failure to progress, pain relief or exhaustion
  • Midwife considered transfer urgent in only 3.4% of intended home births

High Credibility

  • Included all home births involving Certified Professional Midwives in the year 2000
  • 5,418 women in U.S. and Canada who intended to give birth at home as of the start of labor
  • Prospective - every planned home birth was registered in the study prior to labor and delivery

"Outcomes of planned home births with certified professional midwives: large prospective study in North America."
Kenneth C Johnson and Betty-Anne Daviss. BMJ 2005;330:1416 (18 June). This article and related letters to the
editor are available online, free, at http://www.bmj.com. (Use the search feature and type Daviss for the author.)

Resources: homebirth_is_safe.pdf

Blog Posted: Jun 18, 2005
Posted by: Kellie Moeller, CNM
President HomeBirth Experience, Inc.
281-309-8030

BACK